by Red Okktober » Fri Dec 01, 2017 10:35 pm
Fletch wrote:Red Okktober wrote:Fletch wrote:I did't ask that did I? The question in the post you replied to was: What evidence do you have that it was a racist attack? Changing the question indicates an unwillingness to answer.
I don't have any evidence she was attacked by anyone, regardless of race.
Why are you asking such dumb fuck questions? I'm just a bloke on an internet forum, not part of Yorkshire CID. What sort of evidence do you think I might have?
At this stage, we can only discuss the story as seen, and as it stands, she claims to have been beaten up by three Asians. That is all we have to go on. For some reason, you seem convinced she's making it up. Tell us why you think she's making it up.
Is it a hunch, or is it because the alleged attackers are Asian? You must have reasons for being so dismissive of her comments, what are they?
I didn't say she was making it up. I offered an alternative explanation based on what's known/reported, one which didn't include it being a racist attack whereas you...
Red Okktober wrote: Yet some poor woman with half her head caved in, because she's white and her alleged attackers Asian,
I wondered what grounds you had to make that claim? It seems from what you've said now that it was simply another of your knee jerk reactions based on your own prejudices.
So you don't think she's making it up? Or do you? Only it sounds like you do to me.
Do you offer up 'alternative explanations' to all alleged racist attacks, or just this one?
You "wondered what grounds I had to make that claim (that it was an alleged racist attack)" How about this from the report:
"Police described the attack, which began when the trio approached Ms Hurst and launched verbal abuse before pushing and kicking her, as
'racially aggravated'"
That'll be the same report you relied on earlier to tell us the woman had 'fallen down'
[quote="Fletch"][quote="Red Okktober"][quote="Fletch"]
I did't ask that did I? The question in the post you replied to was: [color=#BF00BF]What evidence do you have that it was a racist attack?[/color] Changing the question indicates an unwillingness to answer.[/quote]
I don't have any evidence she was attacked by anyone, regardless of race.
Why are you asking such dumb fuck questions? I'm just a bloke on an internet forum, not part of Yorkshire CID. What sort of evidence do you think I might have?
At this stage, we can only discuss the story as seen, and as it stands, she claims to have been beaten up by three Asians. That is all we have to go on. For some reason, you seem convinced she's making it up. Tell us why you think she's making it up.
Is it a hunch, or is it because the alleged attackers are Asian? You must have reasons for being so dismissive of her comments, what are they?[/quote]
I didn't say she was making it up. I offered an alternative explanation based on what's known/reported, one which didn't include it being a racist attack whereas you...
[quote="Red Okktober"] Yet some poor woman with half her head caved in, [u]because she's white[/u] and her alleged attackers Asian,[/quote]
I wondered what grounds you had to make that claim? It seems from what you've said now that it was simply another of your knee jerk reactions based on your own prejudices.[/quote]
So you don't think she's making it up? Or do you? Only it sounds like you do to me.
Do you offer up 'alternative explanations' to all alleged racist attacks, or just this one?
You "wondered what grounds I had to make that claim (that it was an alleged racist attack)" How about this from the report:
"Police described the attack, which began when the trio approached Ms Hurst and launched verbal abuse before pushing and kicking her, as [b]'racially aggravated'[/b]"
That'll be the same report you relied on earlier to tell us the woman had 'fallen down'