jp761 wrote:Raggamuffin wrote:Rolluplostinspace wrote:Don't become a magistrate fo Gods sake.
I wasn't planning to, but there comes a time when people have to pull themselves up and sort out their own behaviour rather than blame someone or something else.
When it comes to committing crime, people with Psychotic disorders have been deemed unaccountable for their actions. Everything is obviously dealt with case-by-case by leading experts, as it should be.
Someone who has an anxiety or mood disorder though, will have hard job claiming that they didn't know what they were doing, and that they didn't know right from wrong at that moment.
Once again though it's all very much just a case-by-case situation.
"A report by three geriatric psychiatrists suggests mental illness, not economic need, may be what prompts some previously law-abiding elderly people to begin shoplifting late in life. In those cases, shoplifting may be a symbolic attempt to compensate for the loss of a spouse, job, health or independence"
""Children commonly shoplift. Somehow on the way to growing up, most people learn to inhibit the desire to take things. Normally that's a function of the nervous system,"
But
that inhibiting function can be impaired by stress, Alzheimers disease, other mental and organic diseases, even certain medications, the doctors said.
Pretty much the opposite of what you are saying.
Some people will indeed suffer impaired inhibiting function, many due to mental illness. They simply can't help it. I personally remember a VERY famous elderly woman, Lady Isobel Barnett, had up for theft. She had NO IDEA why she had done it. It certainly affects all ages.
https://www.deseretnews.com/article/895 ... FENSE.html