art0hur0moh wrote:LordRaven wrote:McAz wrote:"...people say, “I’m half-Jewish” or “I’m one-quarter Jewish.” That reflects their self understanding. What they need to know, though, is that in the rabbinic Jewish universe, there are categories labelled “Jewish” and “not-Jewish,” but that there is no “part Jewish.” An analogy: it’s like sitting in a poker game and suddenly yelling “GIN!” You know that the hand you hold looks like “gin” (and it does!) but that’s not a hand in the game of poker. “Part Jewish” may be accurate genealogy but Judaism isn’t genealogy."
Rabbi Ruth Adar
Categorising Jewish, part Jewish etc?
I have heard that being done before and it didn't end well.
I assume You are talking about 1930s census in germany?
LordRaven wrote:art0hur0moh wrote:LordRaven wrote:McAz wrote:"...people say, “I’m half-Jewish” or “I’m one-quarter Jewish.” That reflects their self understanding. What they need to know, though, is that in the rabbinic Jewish universe, there are categories labelled “Jewish” and “not-Jewish,” but that there is no “part Jewish.” An analogy: it’s like sitting in a poker game and suddenly yelling “GIN!” You know that the hand you hold looks like “gin” (and it does!) but that’s not a hand in the game of poker. “Part Jewish” may be accurate genealogy but Judaism isn’t genealogy."
Rabbi Ruth Adar
Categorising Jewish, part Jewish etc?
I have heard that being done before and it didn't end well.
I assume You are talking about 1930s census in germany?
No, rather the whole Nazi ideology
Fletch wrote:Gabby wrote:Stooo wrote:jra wrote:I have drunk some huge amounts in the past, but still remember most of what went on. I stay off drinking large amounts of spirits when going out, as that is my Achilles Heel.
Anyway, this year I'll either stay in, go to see a friend locally or take a late night walk into town and observe the piss head fest.
Sometimes it's better to be sober(ish) and watch others from a safe distance make dicks of themselves, both male and female. Hilarious.
I've got past the point where I feel the need to go out on NYE. Done it all before, pretty well.
When you get to a certain amount of alcohol your brain literally runs on ROM instead of backing up to RAM, your brain is in shock and relies on stimulus to keep you surviving rather than making memories.
Dunno what mine runs on... but it ain’t ROM or RAM!
It's RUM
Guest wrote:Why can't people just give it a rest from picking at jra? You're ALL pathetic bullies.
Guest wrote:Why can't people just give it a rest from picking at jra? You're ALL pathetic bullies.
Fletch wrote:That was quite an episode jra. You alright?
Dean wrote:Guest wrote:Why can't people just give it a rest from picking at jra? You're ALL pathetic bullies.
I can’t speak for others, but I enjoy watching his meltdowns.
jra wrote:Dean wrote:Guest wrote:Why can't people just give it a rest from picking at jra? You're ALL pathetic bullies.
I can’t speak for others, but I enjoy watching his meltdowns.
You've never seen me have a meltdown. This is bottom rung of the ladder stuff.
Dean wrote:
I can’t speak for others, but I enjoy watching his meltdowns.
McAz wrote:LordRaven wrote:McAz wrote:"...people say, “I’m half-Jewish” or “I’m one-quarter Jewish.” That reflects their self understanding. What they need to know, though, is that in the rabbinic Jewish universe, there are categories labelled “Jewish” and “not-Jewish,” but that there is no “part Jewish.” An analogy: it’s like sitting in a poker game and suddenly yelling “GIN!” You know that the hand you hold looks like “gin” (and it does!) but that’s not a hand in the game of poker. “Part Jewish” may be accurate genealogy but Judaism isn’t genealogy."
Rabbi Ruth Adar
Categorising Jewish, part Jewish etc?
I have heard that being done before and it didn't end well.
Tell jra about it lest he's goes to war with himself.
jra wrote:McAz wrote:LordRaven wrote:McAz wrote:"...people say, “I’m half-Jewish” or “I’m one-quarter Jewish.” That reflects their self understanding. What they need to know, though, is that in the rabbinic Jewish universe, there are categories labelled “Jewish” and “not-Jewish,” but that there is no “part Jewish.” An analogy: it’s like sitting in a poker game and suddenly yelling “GIN!” You know that the hand you hold looks like “gin” (and it does!) but that’s not a hand in the game of poker. “Part Jewish” may be accurate genealogy but Judaism isn’t genealogy."
Rabbi Ruth Adar
Categorising Jewish, part Jewish etc?
I have heard that being done before and it didn't end well.
Tell jra about it lest he's goes to war with himself.
Why would I...
jra wrote:McAz wrote:LordRaven wrote:McAz wrote:"...people say, “I’m half-Jewish” or “I’m one-quarter Jewish.” That reflects their self understanding. What they need to know, though, is that in the rabbinic Jewish universe, there are categories labelled “Jewish” and “not-Jewish,” but that there is no “part Jewish.” An analogy: it’s like sitting in a poker game and suddenly yelling “GIN!” You know that the hand you hold looks like “gin” (and it does!) but that’s not a hand in the game of poker. “Part Jewish” may be accurate genealogy but Judaism isn’t genealogy."
Rabbi Ruth Adar
Categorising Jewish, part Jewish etc?
I have heard that being done before and it didn't end well.
Tell jra about it lest he's goes to war with himself.
Why would I. Rabbis can say all they like, but it doesn't change the fact there are Jews (full or partly Jewish by heritage) that don't follow Judaism, i.e. non religious Jews.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_atheism
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_is_a_ ... -Jewish%22
This is about ethnicity, not religion.
if born in the same region where there are blood relations yes. there are no egyptians any more. no one remembers the culture well enough.Fletch wrote:jra wrote:McAz wrote:LordRaven wrote:McAz wrote:"...people say, “I’m half-Jewish” or “I’m one-quarter Jewish.” That reflects their self understanding. What they need to know, though, is that in the rabbinic Jewish universe, there are categories labelled “Jewish” and “not-Jewish,” but that there is no “part Jewish.” An analogy: it’s like sitting in a poker game and suddenly yelling “GIN!” You know that the hand you hold looks like “gin” (and it does!) but that’s not a hand in the game of poker. “Part Jewish” may be accurate genealogy but Judaism isn’t genealogy."
Rabbi Ruth Adar
Categorising Jewish, part Jewish etc?
I have heard that being done before and it didn't end well.
Tell jra about it lest he's goes to war with himself.
Why would I. Rabbis can say all they like, but it doesn't change the fact there are Jews (full or partly Jewish by heritage) that don't follow Judaism, i.e. non religious Jews.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_atheism
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_is_a_ ... -Jewish%22
This is about ethnicity, not religion.
It's a religion, not an ethnicity.
Are a white Jew and a black Jew the same ethnicity?
art0hur0moh wrote:LordRaven wrote:art0hur0moh wrote:LordRaven wrote:McAz wrote:"...people say, “I’m half-Jewish” or “I’m one-quarter Jewish.” That reflects their self understanding. What they need to know, though, is that in the rabbinic Jewish universe, there are categories labelled “Jewish” and “not-Jewish,” but that there is no “part Jewish.” An analogy: it’s like sitting in a poker game and suddenly yelling “GIN!” You know that the hand you hold looks like “gin” (and it does!) but that’s not a hand in the game of poker. “Part Jewish” may be accurate genealogy but Judaism isn’t genealogy."
Rabbi Ruth Adar
Categorising Jewish, part Jewish etc?
I have heard that being done before and it didn't end well.
I assume You are talking about 1930s census in germany?
No, rather the whole Nazi ideology
still, consider the labor movement militancy?
Return to The Sleeping Dogs' Arms
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 42 guests